Ministry of Community Development - Free Essay Example

Sample details Pages: 18 Words: 5452 Downloads: 3 Date added: 2017/06/26 Category Statistics Essay Did you like this example? 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 BACKGROUND The Ministry of Community Development, Culture and Gender Affairs (MCDCGA) belongs to the public and service sector in Trinidad and Tobago. This ministry mainly focuses on the concerns of local communities. MCDCGA is said to be the most all-embracing and people centred ministry in the social services. Don’t waste time! Our writers will create an original "Ministry of Community Development" essay for you Create order It comprises of three main departments: community development, culture and gender affairs. It is a bureaucratic organization guided by the bureaucratic philosophy of Max Webber and is performed by the Government via the Public Service Commission. Many views of performance management in public sector are inhibited due to this bureaucratic system of control. 1.1.1 MISSION STATEMENT To partner with our communities, to identify and satisfy their needs through the provision of gender sensitive quality programmes and services, hereby achieving improvement in their standard of living. 1.1.2 VISIONSTATEMENT Playing a leading role in the empowering of communities and the enrichment of lives. 1.2 THE HUMAN RESOURCE DEPARTMENT The human resource department is one of the most fundamental departments within the ministry. They are responsible for the performance management of employees, training and among other functions; they have to ensure that the department abide to the various regulations. 1.2.1 MISSION STATEMENT OF HR The Human Resource Unit of the Ministry of Community Development, Culture and Gender Affairs focuses on linking Human Resources with the strategic goals, business plan and objectives of the Ministry in order to improve business performance and to develop an organizational culture that foster innovation and flexibility. 1.3 RATIONALE This investigation is based on the observation of the present performance management system in the Ministry. These observations include: lack of training and development; and poor employee performances. The inefficiencies in the HR department have a negative impact on staff morale and their ability to perform efficiently in line with the objectives of the Ministry. This study will improve the Human Resource department which will positively impact on other departments in the Ministry. 1.4 AIM AND OBJECTIVES 1.4.1 AIM The aim of this topic is to discover the problems into the effectiveness of the performance management system used to evaluate the performance of employees and to put procedures into place to improve the performance the employees which in turn will improve the ministry. 1.4.2 OBJECTIVES To examine the existing performance of the Ministry in ascertain its current state To inspect the Ministrys performance management system to substantiate its alignment with theory To investigate the custom of the public service and to comprehend the standards and values To determine whether or not the performance management system is designed to develop the employees To achieve an understanding of what has/has not been effective. 2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW The literature review is based on the ideas of previous writers on the topic of Performance Management which would make clearer the objectives of the research. 2.1 Definition of Performance Management Armstrong and Baron (1998) defines performance management as a tactical and incorporated approach in providing constant success to organizations by improving the performance of the people who work in them and by developing the capabilities of teams and individual contributors. According to Hildebrand (1997) a performance management system is the term for conducting performance appraisal, setting goals, communicating expectations, observing, documenting, giving feedback and helping employees to develop skills. If done well, it can help the organisation gain a competitive edge. 2.2 Criticism of the Performance Management System Bevan and Thompson, (cited in Armstrong, 2000) criticised the theoretical model or what they called the textbook definition of the performance management system by describing them as placing too much emphasis on a top down method, focussing on objective settings which they believe underrate the extent to which training, development, and reward systems are driven from the bottom up. They also disparaged the belief that a performance management system model can fit all situations and that many issues involved in making performance management work were under-emphasised. The study that was accomplished by Fletcher and Williams (1992) specified that numerous organisations were a long way from operating an successful performance system as, for most of them, performance management system is the same as performance appraisal or performance related pay or both. They outlined that an effective performance management system is one which: is owned and driven by line management and not by the HR department; emphasis is placed on share corporate goals and values; Performance management is not seen as a packaged solution, but something that has to be developed specifically and individually for each particular organisation, and should apply to all staff, not just part of the managerial group. Schwartz, 1999 described an effective PMS as one which: Informs employees of areas in which they excel and areas where they can improve; Helps employees improve performance, increase productivity and experience personal satisfaction; Provides the organisation with information for human resource planning. 2.3 APPLICATION OF PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT 2.3.1 Planning Maloa (2001) accentuate the importance of planning with his view that at the core of a good performance management rests the conception that the manager and their subordinates will develop a clear idea of what is expected. This should include prioritizing of the key elements among a multitude of tasks that face them every day. Without this, the individual will be overwhelmed by the conflicting demands on time and as a result may fail to make the right decisions. With lucidity of performance expectations, good performance is possible. In support of the above, Finigan (1999) pointed out that in developing performance plans, it is important to define the responsibility of each position in each department and, as part of this process, two questions need to be answered namely: What does the employee need in order to meet performance expectations? and, What does it mean to exceed these expectations? Satterfield (2003) continues by stating that the vital planning activities should include goal setting, amplification of behavioural competencies and how they would apply to the job. Therefore, the outcome of planning should be clear about the goals to be met, responsibilities to be fulfilled and the behaviours that should contribute to team and organisational success. The compilation of job descriptions in the organization can play a significant role in this regard and would assist in establishing a certainty about what the organization expects from its employees. 2.3.2 Managing performance Managing performance has to be an ongoing process of working towards the performance expectations. According to Maloa (2001), it is probably the most neglected area of performance management. In terms of this aspect, the manager, together with the employee, reviews the employees performance on a periodic basis. If it is on target, or exceeding expectations, the manager provides positive comments to keep performance at a high level, but if performance is below expectations, the manager guides the employee in order to achieve improvement. This involves developing strategies with the employee to determine appropriate action plans. Managing this process involves three main activities, namely coaching, counselling and performance review. 2.3.3 Motivation Motivation is a basic element contributing to employee performance issues. Each person is motivated by different factors and different things (Schwartz, 1999). The first step is to figure out what will motivate your employees to do what you hired them to do. The following are views from different theorists on what motivates employees. Various theorists have developed approaches to motivation that will seek to improve performance. (Frederick Taylor, 1964), suggested that money is the primary motivator as workers would be motivated by obtaining the highest possible wages through working in the most efficient manner, based on the assumption that all people are rational, and that they are driven by the need for financial rewards and not interest in the actual work. (Abraham Maslow,1942), in contrast with Taylors view, suggested that the needs of employees can be classified in a hierarchy, represented on a pyramid with the more basic psychological needs lying at the base and each higher level consisting of a particular class of needs. According to Maslow, employees are motivated based on the level of their needs. Whilst this view has an uncomplicated appeal because its message is clear, others claim that it ignores the capacity of people and those around them to construct their own perceptions of needs and how they can be met (Arnold et al., 1998) Vroom (1964) expectancy theory states that motivation should be based on employees performance-outcome expectancy. This means that employees performance depends on what they expect to get for their efforts. 2.3.4 Training and development Staff training and development should be an important activity in any organisation. In this regard, Oakland and Oakland (2002) stressed that training and development of people at work should be recognized as an important part of human resource management. During the 1980s, major changes in many organizations resulted in increasing workloads brought about by the introduction of new technology and wider ranges of tasks. All of this required the provision of training. During the 1990s, initiatives such as TQM, ISO 9000, investors in people and benchmarking, and self-assessment using models such as among others, the BEM (British Excellence Models), further highlighted the need to train employees (DeToro and McCabe, 1997; Marchington and Wilkinson, 1997 in Oakland and Oakland: 2002). Typically, training strategies in organisations require managers to: Play an active role in training delivery (cascade training) and support (including quality tools and techniques); Receive training and development based on personal development plans (PDPs). These plans can be very useful in closing the skill gaps in performance management; Fund training and improvement activities to allow autonomy at local levels for short pay-back investments; and Co-ordinate discussions and peer assessment to develop tailored training plans for individuals. What is particularly noteworthy about the training activities is that they are almost identical to those processes and activities commonly found in the management literature on the theory of training. 2.3.5 Effective communication Communication is in essence the lifeblood of any organisation striving for world-class status. It should permeate any situation or system operating in the organisation and where people are involved. Oakland and Oakland (2002:779) stated that: It is an important facet of people management à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â‚¬Å" be it communication of organisation goals, vision strategy, business policies or communication of facts, information and data. (Collins and Porras, Larkin and Larkin, Purser and Cabana, Yinglin quoted in Oakland and Oakland, 2002). In some organisations business success, regular two-way communication, particularly face-to-face with employees, is identified as an important factor in establishing trust and the feeling of being valued. The two-way communication can also be regarded as a key management responsibility and may include: Ensuring that people are briefed on key issues in language free of jargon. Communicating honestly and as fully as possible on all issues that affect the people Encouraging team members to discuss company issues and giving upward feedback. Ensuring that issues from team members are communicated to senior managers and timely replies given. 2.4 PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL 2.4.1 Distinguishing features of performance management as opposed to Performance appraisal Armstrong (1996:260) corroborated that there are a number of significant differences between performance management and the traditional appraisal schemes. Performance management in its most developed form: Involves all members of the organisation as partners in the process it is not something handed down by bosses to the subordinates; Is based upon agreements on accountability expectations and development plans. It can be seen as part of the normal interactive processes which exist between managers and teams, a continuous process not relying on a once-a-year formal review; Treats the performance review as a joint affair which is primarily concerned with looking constructively towards the future; Focuses on improving performance, developing competencies and releasing potential; Concentrates on self-managed learning giving people the encouragement they need to develop themselves with whatever guidance they need from their managers and the organisation; May not include rating at all if the process is used primarily for development and performance improvement purposes; Recognizes the need for thorough training in the required skills in order to agree on objectives, provide feedback, review performance, and coach and counsel employees; and Apart from the evident confusion regarding the interchangeable usage of the concept of performance appraisal and performance management, organisations use various terminologies to describe the appraisal process. These terms include performance review; annual appraisal; performance evaluation; employee evaluation and merit evaluation (Grobler et al 2002:260). For purposes of this study, the word performance appraisal will be preferred for use especially, in the context of the final performance evaluation for the year, which determines the appropriate reward. It should be pointed out that the appraisal seems to be associated with an annual event where emphasis is on the completion of a form and with the human resources directorate playing a primary role in administration, management and quality control. With the envisaged model, focus will not be on the human resource function but on line managers and their subordinates driving the process and human resources function playing an advisory role. Grote (1996:13) 2.4.2 Criticisms of Performance Appraisal Torrington et al (2005) criticises the appraisal system by emphasising that performance appraisal is often neglected until the time when the next appraisal come around. They also commented that performance appraisal are often bias, prejudice and subjective. It is possible that inconsistent criteria will be applied by different managers when assessing the calibre of subordinates (Schneier et al., 1991) Hendry et al also criticised the appraisal system for which they see as time consuming, bureaucratic, paper driven and top down, with little relevance to organisational performance goals. Beardwell, Holden and claydon (2004) also criticised the appraisal system by stating that often persons who carry out performance appraisals do not always have the right skills and training to conduct appraisals effectively. 2.4.3 360  ° Feedback An appraisal system that is gaining popularity is the 360-degree feedback. This is because the feedback gleaned from this is utilised as important input for career development as well as for training and development. Because of the nature of the multiple source feedback of the 360-degree process, a broad perspective of the individuals strengths and weaknesses are developed which assists them in enhancing their self-insight and in developing their full potential. Garavan, Morley and Flynn (1997) and Theron and Roodt (1999) summed up the above description by stating that the 360-degree feedback is a contrived method of providing a flow of feedback to employees from all directions thus fulfilling the need for providing the individual with a more holistic and useful set of feedback. According to McCarthy and Caravan (2001) these as alternative terms used for the 360-degree feedback. Stakeholder appraisal. Full circle appraisal. Multi-rater feedback. Multi-source assessment. Subordinate and peer appraisal. Group performance appraisal. Multi-point assessment. Multi-perspective assessment. 2.5 CONCLUSION The literature review provided the researcher with useful information on the topic of performance management, giving a clear understanding of the various aspects of the topic from a practical angle. It revealed issues regarding the Performance Management System which exists in MCDCGA, identifying its best practice and shortcomings. 3.0 RESEARCH DESIGN 3.1 Chosen Methodology This research is a dynamic study given that it is designed to determine the effectiveness of a system to bring about change in a particularly controlled environment. The research methodology consistent with this type of study is the phenomenological paradigm; consequently it provided the basis for this research. This methodology will be utilized because according to Collis and Hussey (2003), researchers are not objective, but part of what they observe. They bring their own interest and values to the research as oppose to the positivistic approach which do not regard such subjectivity. The positivistic methodology can also be applied nevertheless; the phenomenological method is selected alone because of the complications in combining the two because they are two extreme paradigms. However, both qualitative and quantitative methods will be used for collection of data. This is called data triangulation (Denzin, 1970) cited in Collis and Hussey. 3.1.1 Primary Research Primary data is obtained from a direct observation of the phenomenon under investigation or is collected personally (Welman and Kruger 2001). To ensure that primary data is collected, interviews, self-administered questionnaires and direct observation methods will be used (Struwig and Stead 2001). For this research in particular, a self-administered questionnaire and interviews will be used as data collection instruments. As Molefe (1997, pg 151) indicates, the primary data are easily obtained from responses to a questionnaire, largely because data sometimes lie buried deeply within the minds and within the attributes, feelings or reaction of people. Furthermore, by providing access to what is inside a persons mind the questionnaire makes it possible to measure what a person knows, likes or dislikes. The questionnaire is therefore a useful tool to determine perception. For the purpose of compiling a competency profile, the interviews are conducted. 3.1.2 Secondary Research Secondary data refers to the information collected by individuals or organisations other than the researcher for other purposes (Welman and Kruger, 2001). The supplementary importance of using secondary data is that it saves time, provides the opportunity to re-analyse existing data and arrive at new conclusions, and save on the cost of doing a research. The secondary data for this research is sourced through literature research and interviews held with persons responsible for the performance management process. 3.2 RESEARCH TOOLS For the purpose of this investigation, two very instrumental data collection tools will be selected, these are; interviews and questionnaires. Interviews and questionnaires are two diverse ways of conversing with people to extract their opinion and views. These two methods of extracting data will be conducted during the month of December 2009, where respondents will be given approximately four weeks to respond, and interviews will also be held during that same period. Verbal permission was granted by the Senior Human Resource Officer upon an official letter of request by the researcher to conduct interviews and questionnaires. 3.2.1 Interviews Black, Richard J (2003) describes interviews as a joint venture between the researcher and the interviewee. The reason for choosing to use an interview is to ensure that the researcher uncovers perception at a senior level. This will involve face-to-face meetings between the researcher and the interviewee. A total of three interviews will be held with the following officers: the Senior Human Resource Officer, the Accountant I, and the Performance Management Schedule Clerk III. These three persons were selected as three persons responsible for executing the performance management system in the Ministry. The procedures used to conducting these interviews were as follows: Construction of draft questions Vetting of draft for accuracy and suitability Confirm appointments with interviewees Meet with interviews by appointments Deliver questions through conversations and record responses/ Analysis of data Documentation of final analysis in a report form 3.2.2 Questionnaires This research tool will consist of a series of questions based on the objectives of and theoretical contents of this research, for the purpose of gathering information from employees of the ministry to gain an understanding from them of what have or have not been effective in relation to the aim and objectives of this research. It is chosen to help participants to give frank and honest answers. The procedures are follows for drafting questionnaires: Construction of draft questions Vetting of draft for accuracy and suitability Pilot testing on a small randomly selected sample size Determination of sample size and composition Distribution of questionnaires Collection of questionnaires Analysis of data collected The questionnaires will be constructed using the a-point likert scale to permit participants to give more perceptive replies and to state if they have no opinion by providing them with some form of rating scale. It is simple for the respondent to complete and simple for the researcher to code and analyse. 3.2.3 Sample Size The sample size refers to a sub-set of a population and should represent the main interest of the study (Collis and Hussey, 2003). Out of a total population of two hundred and fifteen (215) employees, ninety (90) employees will be selected for the sample size, which represents forty-seven (42%) of the total population. This number was chosen to represent the number of employees currently located in the Head Office. The sample size consisted of a mixture of employees from every department within the Head Office in terms of gender, age and positions to allow precision in responses. This sample size is consistent with Collis and Husseys (2003) phenomenological paradigm. Smaller sample sizes have greater chances of error associated with them. Therefore, choosing an appropriate sample size is an obvious strategy for increasing statistical power. 3.3 SUMMARY This chapter provided a theoretical foundation about the research approach and elaborated on the research methodology, the sample, and the data gathering instrument and how it was used. 4.0 INTRODUCTION This chapter analyses and interprets data and further demonstrates the effectiveness of performance management system in MCDCGA based on the theory amassed from the literature review, best practice and the environment within which the Ministry exists. The environment is emphasised because MCDCGA is a crucial agency of the public sector and is governed by constraints within that particular industry. Therefore, to be effective and efficient in this environment, performance in terms of service delivery should be at the centre of the daily activities of the Ministry. 4.1 DISTRIBUTION OF QUESTIONNAIRES AND ANALYSIS OF DATA A questionnaire as shown in Appendix was used as a data-gathering instrument. It consisted of twenty-seven (27) statements using the 4-point likert scale. This instrument was only distributed to the main Head Office of MCDCGA. The other supporting divisions of the Ministry was left out because of difficulties in reaching their geographical locations and because the focus of attention was to test the performance of persons directly related to the performance of the main Ministry and not the sub-divisions who have responsibility for the performances of their own divisions. The data collected was analysed based on the 5 specific group headings which seek to address the key elements of the objectives of this research. The responses based on each grouping were measured against theory and best practice to identify the effectiveness of the PMS under the different headings. 4.1.1 Overall Responses from Questionnaires Out of a Total of ninety questionnaires distributed, all were completed and returned. Therefore, although there was a response rate of 100% of the sample size, the responses actually represents 45% of the total population. The percentages hereon represent the percentage of the total population to give a fair judgement of the views of the entire Ministry. This section of the questionnaire responded to dimensions such as: Gender Age Length of service in MCDCGA In terms of this section, the respondents gender profile consisted of 27% male and 73% female whose length of services range between one and 30 years. The responses were mainly from mature employees and consisted of 100 % between the ages of 20 and under to 60 and over. 4.2.1 Deductions It is important to note that whatever conclusions this study will make later will be the views of a more mature cross-section of the ministry with a fairly long service record and adequately represented by females whose views has a history of oppression. 4.3 ASSESSMENT OF EMPLOYEE DEVELOPMENT The dimensions assessed in this regard were the need for: A system which is essential to the development of the employees Feedback on performance and ways to improve performance Necessary tools and equipment needed to perform effectively Motivation to perform Praise and recognition as rewards for good performances Training for all staff to enhance their performances Training and coaching for underperformers 4.3.1 Description Table 1 shows the responses and statistical representation to the statements developed to reveal whether or not the performance management system is effective in terms of employee development and also the support level based on the agreement to the various hypotheses. 4.3.2 JUSTIFICATION OF HYPOTHESIS This method to assess the employees development was used to determine whether or not the PMS in the MCDCGA is effective in terms of managing the performances of the employees in an attempt to develop there abilities. The seven hypothesis/statements used were developed from the literature research based on theory from various writers on how the PMS is used to develop individuals which identified that an effective PMS is one which is used to improve employee involvement, commitment and motivation by increasing peoples sense of personal value and enhancing the individuals perception of empowerment (Fletcher and Williams, 1992) 4.3.3 INTERPRETATION OF DATA The analysis of the data to assess employee development revealed that 60% of the employees assessed are in support of the hypothesis that the PMS is needed for their individual development. However, the respondents identified areas in hypothesis 5-10, (see table 1) which questions whether the PMS which they so depend on for individual development is being effectively managed in the Ministry. The objective of this part of the research is to establish whether or not the performance management system in the ministry is designed to improve the performance and development of the employees, or is the PMS in the ministry aligned to focus on the organisational structure rather than focusing on the employees. Schwartz, 1999 described an effective PMS as one which: must be able to informs employees of areas in which they excel and areas where they can improve; it helps employees improve performance, increase productivity and experience personal satisfaction; it provides the organisation with information for human resource planning which involves strategies for motivating, rewarding and training its employees. Based on the low levels of support regarding the effectiveness of some key activities of employee development such as reward and recognition, motivation, training, provision of tools and equipment, and managing underperformance, and literature providing key information on employee development and the PMS, it can be deducted that the PMS in the ministry neglects to account for the development of the employees. This goes against performance management principles outlined in the performance management manual in the public service, which also according Torrington and Hall (1998) PMS is a system for developing employee performance, and that performance management is a shared view between the manager and the managed to gain a clear view of what is expected of the employee. 4.4 LINKING EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE TO ORGANISATIONAL PERFORMANCE The dimensions assessed in this regard were the need for: Having a clearer understanding of the ministrys performance. Translating organisational goals into individual goals Identifying what impact the employee has on the ministry overall performance. Informing employees of the, ministrys performance 4.4.1 Description The performance of the ministry is yet another measure of an effective PMS (Bevan and Thompson 1992). The following represents the responses from employees who agree based on responses in Table that: They PMS is designed to improve the Ministrys overall performance (64%) The goals of the ministry are translated into their individual goals (47 %) There performance makes a difference to the ministrys overall performance (73%) They are aware of the performance of the ministry ( 20% ) 4.4.2 JUSTIFICATION OF HYPOTHESIS These hypotheses were used to determine the link between employee and organisational performance. This link is necessary based on the objectives of this, to observe how effective is the PMS in incorporating the performance of employees into the organisational performance. The organisational context, within which employee-centred performance management exists, is in the vision, mission strategy and operational plans of the organisation. While the aim of the present study is to address performance management at an individual level, it also strives to support the organisations goals by ensuring that there is a link between the work of each individual employee or manager to the overall organisational strategy, mission and vision (Williams, 1998). 4.4.3 INTERPRETATION OF DATA Based on the data provided in the table, employees are aware that their performances have a significant impact on the ministrys overall performance however; the majority disagreed to the hypothesis that they are informed of the ministrys performance. Their responses also revealed that there is no proper system in place to translate the Ministrys goals into their individual goals to make a sound contribution to the performance of the ministry. 4.5 ASSESSMENT OF THE PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM The dimensions assessed in this regard were the need for: A clear understanding of what the PMS aim to achieve Understanding the purpose of the PMS Linking PMS to performance improvement Identifying the shortcomings of the system 4.5.1 JUSTIFICATION OF HYPOTHESIS These hypotheses were used as a basis for this research as it seeks to investigate the effectiveness of the PMS. The statements were structured around testing the effectiveness through the perceptions of the employees and are based on the research objectives and theoretical data from the literature review. 4.5.2 INTERPRETATION OF DATA The data collected based on Hypothesis No. 15, revealed that 43% of respondents do not have a clear understanding of what the PMS aim to achieve however, based on Hypothesis No. 16, 87% believed that the purpose of the PMS is to align performance to organisational objectives. This says a lot about the PMS in terms of its effectiveness, since respondents seem to be clue less as to what the PMS really is, however the term Performance management on the whole is usually difficult to define as there is no commonplace definition accepted (Hartle, 1995). Hypothesis #18: The PMS focuses more on organisational performances and less on employee objectives. A total of 73 % of the respondents supported this view, based on Armstrong, (1998), however, the focus now is on people. Its about how individuals work together to achieve shared aims. Hypothesis 21 shows 56% of the respondents have no idea about what their performance standards are, their were also significant percentages revealing that the PMS does not give the employee the opportunity to discuss their performance with their supervisors, thus, based on the responses, the PM system is showing signs of inefficiency. 4.6 ASSESSMENT OF THE PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL The Performance Appraisal/ review are a key component of an effective Performance management framework. These hypothesis statements were developed to get an understanding of how efficient the performance management system is by evaluating the performance appraisal. Hypothesis #23: 87% of the respondents felt that Performance Management is usually only made mention of at the end of the year during the processing of staff reports. Hypothesis #24: 63% of respondents agreed that the performance appraisal assists in improving their performance. Hypothesis # 25: 83 % of respondent agreed that the performance appraisal provides feedback on their performance) In most ministries within the Government services, performance appraisal is conducted once for the year à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â‚¬Å" at the end of each year. Torrington and Hall (1998) found that an effective PMS is one where there is continuous assessment. Performance Appraisals should not rely on once every year, or twice every year, it should be continuous (Armstrong, 2000). Performance appraisals focus on developing and realising competencies, thereby focusing on improving performance, recognising training and feedback. 4.7 SECONDARY DATA: INTERVIEWS Based on the data collected from the questionnaires the following observations were made. There is no formal structure for the PMS. Performance management is seen as appraising employees, although there are clear distinctions between performance appraisal and performance management (Armstrong, 1996) Measuring performance is difficult in terms of productivity and efficiency, because of the nature of the organisation and the industry to which it belong. Performance is measured by punctuality and absenteeism. The present performance management system neglects the supporting activities needed to develop and improve the employees. The ministry seems to progressing well without a formal PMS structure. The appraisal system is highly subjective and does not provide any feedback. Managers are not equipped with the necessary tools to conduct a meaningful appraisal (Breadwell, Holden, Claydon , 2004) Performance is often neglected until the end of the year appraisal. Individual performance is not linked to the ministrys overall performance. The Ministrys vision, mission and objectives are not communicated to staff. 4.8 Conclusion Based on this research and the objectives of this research,, which aligned the current practices of Performance management to theory, it can be concluded that the Performance management system is not effective. RECOMMENDATIONS CONCLUSIONS: 5.1 Recommendations The following recommendations are based on the descriptive and inferential reviews discussed in the previous chapters. It is recommended that a structured/formal process of managing performance be developed to support the staff component and thereby have a meaningful contribution towards organisational development. Training and development across the border to include Managers to better prepare them for conducting meaningful appraisals, and to develop the performance of employees that will impact positively on the performance of the Ministry. Send staff on retreats to keep them informed of the ministrys strategy. This will also give them a sense of belonging that will foster improvements in their overall performance. Reward and recognition strategies could be implemented to reward workers and foster an organisational culture committed to rewarding and recognising performances, whilst at the same time developing strategies to manage poor performances. 5.2 CONCLUSION This chapter gave recommendations about performance management based on the empirical research conducted as well as theory and good practice on the topic. Although the response rate was somewhat low for known reasons, it was however encouraging to note that the organisational climate and culture at MCDCGA was quite receptive to performance management. The research has identified deficiencies in the current performance management system that is in need of being addressed. It is with much hope that the issues addressed in the recommendations be put to use to curb these issues and develop an environment which contributes highly towards high levels of performance, both and the individual and organisational levels.

Essay about Gang Intelligence Methods in Law Enforcement

GANG INTELLIGENCE METHODS IN LAW ENFORCEMENT The American headlines of any large city will site killings on street corners, robberies, assaults, intimidation, and drug interaction. While not all-criminal activity is associated with gangs, the 780,000 strong members do account for a large majority of the problems that are plaguing America. There is no one-way to stop gang activity in one single swipe, but through a combination of cooperation, education, and training techniques law enforcement can minimize the gang’s movements and even stop a crime before it is committed. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;A gang is defined as a group of individuals with the same objective that are bound together by a bond of trust. The majority of gangs are†¦show more content†¦The street cop is often in the best position to get good first hand information. The majority of the problems in any jurisdiction tend to occur in a certain area of the district, and the street cop is the official that is usually on the scene first. This gives that individual the advantage of the moment, as well as first hand knowledge on what crimes are continually committed, identifying any patterns, and visually seeing the same faces in the surrounding area of the crime. This type of intelligence must be quickly relayed in order to stay ahead of possible gang related activity. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Another type of information collection comes by the way of open source intelligence. The Internet is a powerful tool and recent advances have made it easier to retrieve specific knowledge (Peterson 2000, 83). Information can be drawn from web sites or chat rooms that are advertising position openings within a gang for new members. The problem with the information highway is that it may sometimes be a little overwhelming and time consuming in order to find useful information. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;The news media is another source of collection within the open source intelligence discipline. The media may be the first to a gang-related crime scene or could be doing an inside story on a gang. One major advantage to working with the news media is there is always a camera atShow MoreRelatedEssay on Gangs in America787 Words   |  4 PagesChoose a law enforcement agency. Detail that agencys plan of action to combat the violence of a particular gang. List real world examples. Discuss what is currently being done to combat drug violence, and describe the effectiveness of these tactics. U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency The mission of the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) is to enforce the controlled substances laws and regulations of the United States and bring to the criminal and civil justice system of the United States, orRead MoreThe Criminal Aspect of Social Media1360 Words   |  5 PagesWhen the term social media is used, both law enforcement and the general public most often think of the ability to either connect publically or share content through internet based social networking sites such as: Facebook; Twitter; YouTube or Instagram. Facebook alone has over 1.3 billion users who post more than 350 million photos and 20 million videos a day to their accounts. YouTube has over 800 million users that upload 65 hours of video every minute of every day. Twitter has over 645 millionRead MoreCriminal Intelligence and Violent Crime Essay1094 Words   |  5 PagesCrime Intelligence Analysis Violent Crimes Katelyn Shawver American Military University Introduction Criminal intelligence analysis is useful in many areas to law enforcement. It is especially useful in apprehending violent criminals and preventing violent crimes. Violent crimes in the United States have been on a moderate decline over the past decade. This decline has been attributed to the crime analysis intelligence used by law enforcement. Prevention of violent crimeRead MoreGang Report On Gang Groups840 Words   |  4 Pages2013 National Gang Report, gangs continue to flourish, progress, and develop criminal tradecrafts (p. 3). Based on state, local, and federal law enforcement reporting, the National Gang Intelligence Center (NGIC) calculated that the US gang composition is approximately 88 percent street gang members, 9.5 percent prison gang members, and 2.5 percent outlaw motorcycle gang (OMG) members. Street gangs pose the most violent and significant threat in most communities, while prison gangs are viewed asRead MoreEssay on MS-13: A Dangerous Gang1167 Words   |  5 PagesFor many Americans MaraSalvatrucha or commonly known on the streets as (MS-13) is an unfamiliar gang but to (FBI) Federal Bureau Investigation,(ATF) Alcohol, Tabaco, Firearms and Explosives, and local law enforcement agencies,MS-13 is an uprising globalized menace of ruthless criminals who are growing in numbers exponentially. These plagues of criminals are not only making their mark here in the United States but they are deeply rooted in their country of origin, El Salvador and all throughout CentralRead MoreTheories Of Crime Analysis Spring1300 Words   |  6 Pages Policing is to regulate, control, or keep in order with a law enforcement agency or other official group. It is a job done every minute of every hour of everyday by men and women willing to risk their health and life. To make the job easier different styles or types of policing methods have been developed. Some of the most influential types of policing include community oriented policing, problem oriented policing and intelligence led policing. Community oriented policing or community policingRead MoreGang Violence And The United States1470 Words   |  6 PagesGangs have been a part of American culture in the United States since the early 19th century when immigrant youth organized themselves into street gangs as a means of urban and economic survival. Today, gang violence has reached an almost catastrophic level in the United States. Criminal street gangs have become one of the most serious crime problems in California. Gang violence accounts for one of the largest personal threats to public safety for nearly all the cities in this state. Salinas, CaliforniaRead MoreThe Toronto Anti Violence Intervention Strategy1564 Words   |  7 Pagesconstructs (e.g., personality characteristics, neighbourhood characteristics, immigrant concentration). For instance, Papachristos, Meares, Fagan (2012) propose that young people from neighborhoods saturated with criminal associates and opportunities for gang-related activities and dr ug trafficking, more likely to become young offenders. The perceived legitimacy of the risk factors, in turn, increases public compliance with legal authorities—the belief that behavior of young people needs to come into lineRead MoreBehavioral Analysis Unit1076 Words   |  5 Pagesvictims, including abductions, mysterious disappearances of children, homicides, and sexual victimization. The behavioral analysis units use the method of Criminal profiling which is the process of identifying major characteristics of a criminal’s personality and behavior based on a careful analysis of the crimes they have committed. The method of criminal profiling is quickly becoming increasingly popular to use in criminal investigations. Despite its popularity, the process is met with muchRead MorePolice Department And Other Agencies Within The Criminal Justice System Essay1544 Words   |  7 Pages6 departmental units that will be included on the task force from the Virtual Police Department. Our Patrol and Investigations commanders will lead the way in leading the unit to stopping this unethical crime. Our Patrol, Narcotics/Vice, Criminal Gangs and Canine units will lead the charge in the field! They will investigate and leave no stone unturned until we find the individuals we are looking for. We will also use our Evidence Locker to store any evidence that we collect as we build our case

The novel Jekyll and Hyde Free Essays

Written in the 1880’s by famous British author Robert Louis Stephenson, the novel Jekyll and Hyde is about one man with dissociative personalities. Jekyll and Hyde, although are portrayed to be two very different characters all together, are in fact the same man, wanting to fulfil certain â€Å"evil† pleasures whilst still being a well respected member of society. However both of these desires cannot be overcome without a magic potion created by Dr Jekyll, used to transform himself into the ghastly looking and somewhat evil being, known in this book as Hyde – his other half. We will write a custom essay sample on The novel Jekyll and Hyde or any similar topic only for you Order Now In the late 1800’s there were a few ideas and theories arising which could be what inspired Stephenson to write such an odd and interesting book. The significant developments in ideas which could be associated with this story are Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution and Sigmund Freud’s psychological theories on dissociative personalities, which came around at the time of Stephenson writing this book. These could be linked to how Hyde is from an era where there was no such thing as morality, Hyde can also link to Freud’s id (animal instinct), ego (what controls us in order to achieve others approval) and superego (sense of self), in this way Jekylls id takes over. Stephenson could also be proving a point about the class system at that time in the UK as there was a large class division, where as Jekyll has a rich, well off posh lifestyle and Hyde is a character who is â€Å"crude† and appears to be of a lower class, not at all respected in the society in which he lives. The first example of Stephenson portraying Hyde as being evil comes midway though the first chapter where he is first described as â€Å"a little man stumping along. † Already he is portrayed to have an ugly negative appearance, and his physical descriptions are one of the main ways which Stephenson describes Hyde overall. Next he is shown to knock over a small child in the street, and one may assume this was an accident, and it most likely was, however when Hyde shows no affection to the girl he just knocked over, and literally tramples over her, the audience knows he is a bad character. Mr Enfield (a friend of the lawyer; Mr Utterson) after seeing this describes the incident as â€Å"hellish† and Hyde as â€Å"a damned juggernaut†, which relates Hyde to becoming violent as the Indian God of war known as Jaggernafth. Here he is also compared to Satan, which refers him to evil yet again. Another way in which Stephenson portrays Hyde to be evil is through his physical descriptions, however there is a vagueness of his facial descriptions due to the fact other people find him indescribably ugly. In chapter 8 he is said by Poole (Jekylls butler) to â€Å"have a mask upon his face† as such an appearance is too inhuman and unnatural to be that of a normal man. Also in that chapter Hyde is commonly referred to as â€Å"it† rather than â€Å"him† which suggest he has a lack of humanity. He is also called a â€Å"creature† and described as having a dismal screech, as of mere animal terror. This creates a sense of animal imagery, which is one of the ways that Stephenson portrays Hyde as being evil. Hyde’s clothes are described to be far too big, and that is because they are the exact same clothes worn by Dr Jekyll. This therefore shows that Jekyll is considerably taller than Hyde, and Stephenson here could be saying that not only does Jekyll overshadow Hyde in a physical sense, but also in the sense that the good in Jekyll is much greater than the evil in Jekyll. Dr Jekyll is a rather interesting character who wants and respects his good reputation, but still craves some of life’s somewhat quirky pleasures. Should we question if Jekyll is as morally good as people, such as his close friends think he is, or if he is simply a scientist with urges to fulfil? In chapter ten Jekyll describes his â€Å"duplicity† and he also describes his first feelings of his â€Å"new life† as Hyde. After the â€Å"racking pangs† of the initial transformations, Jekyll describes himself as feeling â€Å"indescribably new† and â€Å"incredibly sweet†. He feels â€Å"younger, lighter happier in body† and he also talks about the â€Å"freedom† of his soul, what is also interesting is how he felt â€Å"wicked† yet delighted. This is the first point in which the audience know Jekyll and Hyde are in fact one, but also that Jekyll enjoys his transformation from good to evil. This idea of Jekyll enjoying his transformation suggests that maybe Jekyll is actually not so morally good. Also Jekyll describing his † dual nature† and saying â€Å"I concealed my pleasures† also go to show maybe Jekyll isn’t the most morally good character which goes beside other character opinions on him such as Dr Lanyon’s â€Å"He began to go wrong in the mind. He does however get more pleasing and positive descriptions at the start of the story, where Mr Utterson compliments him, saying he is a â€Å"well-made, smooth faced man† who throws â€Å"pleasant dinners† and who’s personality was one of sincerity. As well as himself, his house is described as â€Å"comfortable† â€Å"warmed† by Utterson which could reflect Dr Jekyll as a person. On top of this, the den otations â€Å"F. R. S. are next to his name, which stand for Fellow of the Royal Society, and to be in such a highly respected club portrays Jekyll as a man with a much esteemed reputation and a man of high intellect. These qualities of Jekyll alongside others like his â€Å"nature to industry† and â€Å"high head† that when put against his dark secrets and new good feelings after his first transformation, show that Jekyll is generally good but is only human so he will have his secrets, which as deep as they may be, show that he is not evil, but nobodies perfect? From reading this book, it is clear to see that Stephenson uses several ways to show the true personalities of Jekyll and Hyde. The first way in which Hyde is depicted to be evil is through the descriptions of his actions, in Chapter one he is described to be stumping along and this creates a sense of negativity rather than just walking. The violence and severity of the verbs Stephenson uses also contribute to the portrayal of Hyde’s evil nature. He also uses animal imagery such as â€Å"ape-like fury† which compares him to an animal, a creature with no morals, and of a lower class. Then there is Jekyll, who Stephenson portrays to be the complete opposite of Hyde, and does this by talking about his privileged background, good stature and good looks, and also gives him the title Dr rather than Mr, as anyone would think of a Dr as a well respected and highly intellectual member of society. How to cite The novel Jekyll and Hyde, Papers

Quantitative Research and Black Males free essay sample

On the run: Wanted men in a Philadelphia Ghetto. American Sociological Association, 74(3), 339-357. After reading the article, it was clear that it was written to give insight on what really happens in black neighborhoods and how daily lives are affected. Goffman’s (2009) purpose is to show that, â€Å"Although recent increases in imprisonment are concentrated in poor Black communities, we know little about how daily life within these neighborhoods is affected† (p. 39). Additionally, there are no research questions directly stated, but are implied throughout the article as to how exactly prejudice and racism towards the black communities can affect a black person’s life and to those around him. The major independent variable in the analysis is that over the years, young black males with little or no education have been imprisoned at least once in their life. The number of people being incarcerated keeps growing. The dependent variable ,or effect, of this cause is how being incarcerated even just once, can affect their daily lives in getting employment and always being on the run because of fear of being incarcerated again. The article did show theoretical frameworks as part of the literature review which focused on young uneducated black males. This article focused on the failure of young black men’s color, on how they could get arrested just by being seen as a black male. Other research and/or studies would focus on the â€Å"ghetto,† not just as a black male ghetto, but possibly people from other origins who live in ghettos such as Latino gang members. Goffman (2009) focuses only on black male gender theory. Both quantitative and qualitative research methods were used in the article. For quantitative methods, a percentage of black males being imprisoned were shown. As evidence, Pettit and Western (2004) stated, â€Å"30 percent of those with only high school diplomas have been to prison, and 60 percent of those who did not finish high school have prison records by their mid-30s,† (p. 39). Wildeman (2009) also stated, â€Å"One in four Black children born in 1990 had a father imprisoned,† (p. 339). For the qualitative method, Goffman (2009) used descriptive events and places that she was actually involved and observed in. The research design made the article more understanding and interesting by giving us a clear picture of how pe rcent numbers grew for black males being incarcerated and how the outcome of it affected their daily lives. In order to obtain information for the article, Goffman (2009) would actually spend time hanging out with young male men who had a record of being incarcerated and living in a bad neighborhood where cop surveillance had increased. Goffman (2009) would be, â€Å"spending most of my waking hours hanging out on Chuck’s back porch steps, or along the alley way between his block and Mike’s block,† and â€Å"for the next four years I spent two and six days a week on 6th street and roughly one day a week visiting members of the group in jail and prison,† (p. 42). The data collection Goffman (2009) obtained consisted of observations and actually taking field notes with the young men’s consent, although she would not directly ask questions. Goffman (2009) used quotes of what people would say by, â€Å"typing it down directly onto a laptop or by using a cell phone text message,† (p. 342). She also interviewed lawyers, police officers, probation officer s and a judge to get more research information for the article. Goffman (2009) analyzed the data she obtained by observing actual events that went on in Black communities and placing them in the article very descriptively. They were systematically described by the events being in order and giving readers a clear view of imagining what exactly was happening. As a result of all the evidence put together, Goffman (2009) found out that because black males had been incarcerated they were the main target of being incarcerated again because of their color, due to this fact they live in fear of going back to jail and are always on the run. They cannot keep a decent life and those around them such as family, friends, and girlfriends use the fact that they can be incarcerated again to their advantage to get money, keep them â€Å"in check†, and to get payback if they’ve been done wrong by them. Goffman (2009) also stated that, â€Å"Young men also turn their wanted status into a resource by using it to account for shortcomings or failures that may have occurred anyway,† (p. 354). These findings are accurately and adequately described so that readers can evaluate the claims and have a good picture of how their lives are affected. The research findings matter to me in a sense that I now have a much broader understanding on what black males go through in the type of neighborhoods that they live in. I was able to see how prejudice and racism also play a big role in young black male men being the target of being incarcerated. The issue in American society that may have shaped this article and research is racism because due to a male’s color they are automatically suspected of doing something wrong and whether or not they’ve done something wrong at the time they are taken to jail. Very much creditability should be given to the research and findings of this article because it helps us see the side of the story we did not know about. The research is solid and very useful because it helps us understand how and why young male black men live in fear and can’t lead a normal life without actually being caught by authorities. Goffman’s (2009) article helps provide a new outlook on how lives are in fact affected in Black neighborhoods.